top of page

The Zestimate Trap: Why Zillow's Number Isn't Your Home's Value!

Writer: Tom Andre, Assoc. Broker, REALTOR®
Tom Andre, Assoc. Broker, REALTOR®
May 12
2 min read

You've poured years of care into your home. New HVAC. Updated kitchen. A roof that doesn't keep you up at night. You deserve to know what it's actually worth.


But there's a problem.


Zillow's Zestimate is an algorithm - not an appraisal. And it's working with bad data more often than you'd think.


County tax records - Zillow's primary source - frequently get square footage wrong. A finished basement? Sometimes counted, sometimes not. That discrepancy alone can swing a Zestimate by tens of thousands of dollars.


But it goes deeper. Zillow doesn't know that you replaced your HVAC last year, updated your kitchen, got a new roof, or maintained your home meticulously for the last 15 years. Nor does it know the specific details of any of those things.


What if you choose a 50-year shingle when replacing the roof, not the 15-year shingle? And, how about that transferable warranty, wouldn't that land differently - than some guy doing it out of the back of a pickup truck?


It also doesn't know if you've done nothing since you bought it.


And those listing photos? Often pulled from the last time it sold. Zillow is literally tying your home's value to a snapshot from the past - not what it looks like today. The same one the seller referenced during that pre-listing appointment.


Would you buy a used car with a five-year-old CarFax? It would be neither up-to-date nor accurate. Wouldn't you want an up-to-date CarFax?


Zillow is referenced in almost every real estate conversation I have.


An algorithm can't walk your floors, notice your upgrades, or feel the difference between a well-loved, upgraded home and a neglected one.


Your home deserves a real evaluation and assessment from a real human - a professional. Not guess from the Internet - using yesterday's information.


Here's what I'll do. I'll walk your property, account for every upgrade, every system you've replaced, every dollar you've invested - and give you an honest, current market valuation based on what your home is actually worth today. No algorithms. No guesswork. No five-year-old photos.


Stop wondering. Start knowing.

📞 Call or text Tom Andre at 678-472-1934-1934🌐 wwwConsultingAndre.com] 📩 Tom@ConsultingAndre.com 


The zestimate trap zillows number isnt your homes value

Tom Andre, Associate Broker, 3rd generation REALTOR® is with Atlanta Communities since 2009. He serves homeowners and buyers across places in north metro Atlanta like East Cobb, Roswell, Johns Creek, and Alpharetta.

Tom Andre of Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage - East Cobb / Marietta, GA
Tom Andre
Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage
Tom Andre
Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage
Atlanta Communites - East Cobb / Marietta, GA

Comments


Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage logo

3113 Roswell Rd. #101, Marietta, GA 30062  |  Tom@ConsultingAndre.com  |  (o) 770-240-2001 | (c) 678-472-1934

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Google map Link To Tom Andre
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Twitter now X.com
  • Yelp Link To Tom Andre
  • TikTok
Realtors (NAR)
tom-andre-footer-logo-atl-gold.png
Seniors, Aging Baby Boomers
Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage awards: Atlanta Business Chronicle #2 top real estate brokerage by 2025 sales volume; #16 East Cobb office, top 20 real estate offices by 2025 sales volume; RealTrends 2025 rankings #47 transactions, #24 independent US real estate firms, #53 sales volume in the US; RealTrends 500 Company 2025; Atlanta Business Chronicle #2 top brokerage by 2023 sales volume.

© 2026 Tom Andre, Associate Broker  |  Atlanta Communities Real Estate Brokerage, LLC  |  Office: (770) 240-2001

bottom of page